The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has filed a notice of appeal in its ongoing lawsuit against Ripple Labs, challenging a previous court ruling that found XRP is not inherently a security. The appeal, filed on October 2, 2024, seeks to overturn key aspects of Judge Analisa Torres’ July 2023 decision that partially favored Ripple.
In her original ruling, Judge Torres determined that programmatic sales of XRP on secondary markets did not constitute securities transactions. However, she also found that Ripple’s sales to institutional investors did violate securities laws. The SEC’s appeal could potentially target either or both of these findings.
Ripple Considers Cross-Appeal as XRP Price Tumbles
Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, expressed disappointment with the SEC’s decision to continue litigation. In a statement, Alderoty said, “This case has been a complete embarrassment for the SEC from the start.” He noted that Ripple is considering filing a cross-appeal by October 18, potentially challenging the institutional sales ruling or the $125 million penalty imposed in August.
The legal uncertainty has impacted XRP’s market performance. Following the SEC’s appeal notice, XRP’s price dropped approximately 11%, trading at $0.5331 at press time.
Interestingly, the appeal comes amid signs of growing institutional interest in XRP. Bitwise recently filed for an XRP ETF trust in Delaware, though SEC approval may now be delayed due to the ongoing legal battle.
In a related development, SEC enforcement chief Gurbir Grewal announced his resignation just hours before the appeal was filed. This personnel change has raised questions about the agency’s approach to crypto regulation going forward.
As the case moves to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, the crypto industry will be watching closely. The outcome could have far-reaching implications for how digital assets are classified and regulated in the United States.
Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse remains defiant, stating, “XRP’s status as a non-security for programmatic sales remains unchanged despite the SEC’s appeal.” He criticized the agency for “squandering taxpayer funds on a losing fight.”
Arslan Butt serves as the Lead Commodities and Indices Analyst, bringing a wealth of expertise to the field. With an MBA in Behavioral Finance and active progress towards a Ph.D., Arslan possesses a deep understanding of market dynamics.His professional journey includes a significant role as a senior analyst at a leading brokerage firm, complementing his extensive experience as a market analyst and day trader. Adept in educating others, Arslan has a commendable track record as an instructor and public speaker.His incisive analyses, particularly within the realms of cryptocurrency and forex markets, are showcased across esteemed financial publications such as ForexCrunch, InsideBitcoins, and EconomyWatch, solidifying his reputation in the financial community.